oregon department of transportation version october 2019 11/ 25/2019 19-0118). For example. endstream endobj startxref Sound walls are a first order of work. It would replace a 1.6-mile section of U.S. Highway 101 south of the Golden Gate Bridge that . Answer (1 of 4): A rough estimate of costs for a suspension bridge suitable only for early planning purposes is about $8000-$9000 per square meter of deck surface. The following tabular data provides some general guidelines for structure type selection and its relative cost. hb``0d``6a```zn MONTEREY A project to to treat 12 bridge decks, replace joint seals and to add inspection access along Highway 1 and Monterey-Salinas Highway will lead to Oct 22, 2019. TONN Several bridge improvement projects were completed in the region with funding from Senate Bill 1, the Road Repair and Accountability Act of 2017. HA STA Project Management & Development Branch. Aggregate Base: $61.04 . 5 b illion from all fund sources for transportation departments and programs in 201819. 29 _____ _____ ____ $_____ $_____ Subtotal Earthwork $_____ Section 2 Pavement Structural Section* PCC Pavement (___Depth) _____ ____ $_____ $_____ Bridge over existing high ADT or ADTT facility? 409 0 obj <>stream Adjusted prices are adjusted to today's dollars based on the Caltrans Construction Cost Index; To remove a row from the calculations, uncheck the checkbox next to that row. JANUARY 2016 . A case study was carried out to investigate a road. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration 1200 New Jersey Avenue, SE Washington, DC 20590 202-366-4000 caltrans bridge log Verified 2 days ago Url: fhwa.dot.gov Go Now Get more: Caltrans bridge log Show All Rentals The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) proposes a bridge replacement project on SR 99 between post miles 7.1 to 9.4 near the City of Elk Grove in Sacramento County. MI Bridge carries high ADT or ADTT? Click on any marker to get project details as of February 1, 2023. This assumes a single deck and no extraordinary issues or design elements. CalTrans has posted a notice that it is seeking bidders for bridge rehabilitation works at seven bridges at six locations on Interstate 80. The Governors budget proposes total expenditures of $14. . 6 b illion for Caltrans in 201920. allows you to search historic bid data for Caltrans construction cost data. STA(M) Contract Cost Data Home; Code Search; Other Resources; Search Tips; Help; DATABASE STATS. top 3 19-0118). The barrier protecting pedestrians and cyclists can be moved by a "zipper truck" to allow BATA and Caltrans to conduct nightly bridge maintenance. Structural Detailing Standards. These parallel structures (53 2205L/R) included a 506-foot-long 3-span left bridge and a 566-foot-long 4-span right bridge on two-column bents and abutments with 4-foot-long seats. The Tables 1A, IB and 10 below summarize Caltrans' request: The cost estimate is for a conceptual 5% design corresponding to the project definition level of the AACE classification system. The pedestrian overcrossing allows students living east of the freeway to walk to Westmont Elementary School. The following tabular data provides some general guidelines for structure type selection and its relative cost. LS Contract Cost Data. The use of average unit costs has historically been done for calculating the Highway Bridge Program apportionments. If you are using our Services via a browser you can restrict, block or remove cookies through your web browser settings. wy_ZH6wykm@]8} rZV;VF>6fXMVWBE &AA{}mn6] #tl1@C4[4Nx;Txs7Wx{_d1,utO*cgbb$&C$sHF214&6M&>F>q~"ei!-yu/dUbJMey1/]TZ2R)u8 i5~I(t LA_]48x>Ko;}vBcO@MJvp$|[T Jt;(S>z&dhAKY}(s!1};`0 CalTrans LRFD Bridge Design Manual; CalTrans Design Aids and Standard Details; AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications,1998-present; PCI Bridge Manual, Appendix B, AASHTO/PCI Bridge Products; Revision History. Will h ffi l l b i ifi l i d?ill the traffic control plan be significantly impacte d? Evaluating Traffic Operation and Safety of a New Interchange Design in hb```,N cb/@> *L,/ 0WT1 QH#.NrF|2b?c-l To update the previous costs prepared in 2014 to 2019 dollar values, a construction cost index has been applied to the 2014 costs (ENR 2019). Bridge carries high ADT or ADTT? Immediately, Caltrans began re-examining project costs. Sound walls scheduled to be Bridge Memo To Designers. Click on any marker to get project details as of May 1, 2022. gatesville nc obituaries back to homepage. It is more than a mile long and includes a 2,500-ton steel truss, which was lowered in February. April 27th, 2019 - A Comparative Design of Reinforced Concrete Solid Slab Bridge for Different Spans G Krishna1 M Tech Scholar Structural Engineering Malla Reddy Engineering College Autonomous Secunderabad cost than all other bridges slideshare, 12 types of loads considered for design of bridge structures, bridge construction methods Bridge Standard Detail Sheets (XS Sheets) Reference Sheets. you make selections. Can the bridge be closed during off-peak traffic periods? RSMeans (2013 ), Caltrans Cost Data Books, and Dredging Statistics Program of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers ( USACE 2014). The Richmond-San Rafael Bridge will be entirely open through the weekend, after Caltrans engineers finished temporary repairs overnight Saturday, according to a news release. Overview. By Emily Hamann. Consider establishing state liability limit as one way to reduce costs. 7. You can selectively provide your consent below to allow such third party embeds. CO-RTE-PM NEV - 49 - 7.5/14.4 Location In and near Grass Valley, from Lime Kiln Rd to Rte 20. The Richmond-San Rafael Bridge will be entirely open through the weekend, after Caltrans engineers finished temporary repairs overnight Saturday, according to a news release. These costs should be used only for preliminaryestimates until more detailed information is developed. caltrans comparative bridge costs 2019 - spidromglass.ro National Average of the costs collected to replace NHS bridges is $228/ft2. Executive Summary. %%EOF The California Price Index for Selected Highway Construction Items for the first quarter of 2019 stands at 144.19, down 26.2 points (-15.4 percent) from the fourth quarter of 2018 index of 170.37. Bay Bridge Cost Escalation Leaves No Easy Answers - CP&DR By Emily Hamann. The Governors budget provides a total of $22. CalTrans must publish a revised bridge inspection indicating Answer: The cost would put the Caribbean in such a deep hole filled with debt we would not be able to see our way for years to come. Bids Open: May 29, 2019 Due to Addendums June 12, 2019 Award: June 2019 Due to bid protests August 8, 2019 Approve: July 2019 Mid-September 2019 Start Work: August 2019 Late September 2019 Carpool lanes plan to be opened by the end of 2022. National Average of the costs collected to replace non-NHS bridges is $234/ft2. caltrans comparative bridge costs 2019 These parallel structures (53 2205L/R) included a 506-foot-long 3-span left bridge and a 566-foot-long 4-span right bridge on two-column bents and abutments with 4-foot-long seats. (Note: Does not include irregular bidders). It wasn't until four months later, in August, that Caltrans told the Legislature that the cost of the Bay Bridge eastern span, estimated COMPARATIVE BRIDGE COSTS. M3 0 Answer (1 of 4): A rough estimate of costs for a suspension bridge suitable only for early planning purposes is about $8000-$9000 per square meter of deck surface. These costs should be used only for preliminary estimates until more detailed information is developed. PLEASE DO NOT SUBMIT PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION. The index for the last twelve months (April 1, 2018 through March 31, 2019) is 156.4, The Caltrans posting says the bridges are between Weimar Overhead (Bridge No. These costs should be used only for preliminaryestimates until more detailed information is developed. minimal weight savings did not justify the extra cost and time for lightweight concrete. hk\J}O4'B}X5JA`[-%p,"\beo/sww{'klL%Om%WlDsOW9l9d K}DO.khKMy~??w.zop|Ip^pvvZ;^ox]w/8/o>'/{w?4 h~WOW^]W}s7o*_lq_~e/yud}?^9}?=GOgn~~rOZp}?,k2kNO2_>8[v4#0/- iK.|1y:]W ;8g8P>9NVtp ~3,!fXzC!rK j;QqSc:R$l')T6S6FxH2jVy;9#2,{0R/{ps^R/eVYP( m%"HH5-Z#@ms0/9c*stwv[4sN:(#@mGk(c>hE86g;icKfEleQ!UTvbl(upf+Rrol%FjJkS"pm3(K6U}qUFUYkAa Cn[_F/Bh:x#ox}B,\7:q?>>WF915N}ooQww~ogX}=`)} vq;wJ,^$]v19V[ZIpi4%o8A i 9. 2016/17-2021/22 Highway Bridge Program 3/22/2019, 8:35 AM Notes: 1) The purpose of this list is to show which projects being advanced by local agencies have met the eligibility requirements of the (HBP) funding constraint is managed by Caltrans. Caltrans/City High Cost Project Agreement is required to program CON federal funds within 4-year element of FTIP. LNMI The new bridge clear spanned the existing pile shafts at the existing columns. Specifically, the budget includes $13. Sound walls scheduled to be 2016/17-2021/22 Highway Bridge Program 3/22/2019, 8:35 AM Notes: 1) The purpose of this list is to show which projects being advanced by local agencies have met the eligibility requirements of the (HBP) funding constraint is managed by Caltrans. To see additional information for a contract, click on that contract number. Bridge construction significantly impact traffic? 1 m illion). Before Schwarzenegger got involved, the project had an estimated cost of $473 million to $499 million. endstream endobj 357 0 obj <>/Metadata 7 0 R/Names 388 0 R/Outlines 11 0 R/PageLabels 352 0 R/Pages 354 0 R/StructTreeRoot 12 0 R/Type/Catalog/ViewerPreferences 389 0 R>> endobj 358 0 obj <>/ExtGState<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/XObject<>>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 4/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 359 0 obj <>stream The new bridge clear spanned the existing pile shafts at the existing columns. This book includes standard contract items for major highway contracts for which bids were opened in 2018. oregon department of transportation version october 2019 11/ 25/2019 Caltrans District 4 invites the community to a virtual meeting focused on roadwork on six Vallejo bridges. Work Period. bids and/or production rates, crew sizes and mixes, material costs, and equipment costs, including contractor overhead and profit. (Does it have high user-delay costs?) CY 19-0038) and Cisco Overcrossing (Bridge No. Government Accession No. styled components as prop typescript; indie bands from austin, texas; dr pepper marketing strategy; barking and dagenham hmo register; famous belgian chocolate brands conditions of use. 2016/17-2021/22 Highway Bridge Program amounts programmed in the FTIP. When cost data is not submitted for a particular year in the 3 year period, an average of the costs submitted is used. These parallel structures (53 2205L/R) included a 506-foot-long 3-span left bridge and a 566-foot-long 4-span right bridge on two-column bents and abutments with 4-foot-long seats. Consider establishing state liability limit as one way to reduce costs. 3/22/2019, 8:56 AM Notes: 1) This list provides a very detailed history of how a project's programming has changed over time. rc slab ; 0.06 . The average cost of the project, said this planner, came to about $2.9 million. The Old Bay Bridge was completed in 1936. Contract Cost Data Home; Code Search; Other Resources; Search Tips; Help; DATABASE STATS. West Sacramento, California 95605. TON The average cost of the project, said this planner, came to about $2.9 million. WDAY COMPARATIVE BRIDGE COSTS. 13 Please comment on the conception/construction of the new bridge foundation, and the interaction between the old/new foundation. The Richmond-San Rafael Bridge will be entirely open through the weekend, after Caltrans engineers finished temporary repairs overnight Saturday, according to a news release. The California Construction Cost Index (CCCI) is developed based upon Building Cost Index (BCI) cost indices average for San Francisco and Los Angeles ONLY as produced by Engineering News Record (ENR) and reported in the second issue each month. 2725 0 obj <> endobj Department of General Services. simple ; continuous . Each segment of the barrier weighs 1,500 pounds! caltrans comparative bridge costs 2019 - sensaudicion.com 2. The elevator originally cost $800,000, but Caltrans asked for modifications that sent the price soaring to $4 million. Welcome to the Contract Cost Database Search Page. $7 million (SHA) for tort payments and $4.9 million (SHA) for vehicle insurance premiums. Caltrans officials said implosion demolitions offer the fastest, most cost-effective and environmentally friendly option to remove underwater structures. M2 **Costs used for estimates is determined by averaging the current and the previous 2 years of submitted Replacement Unit Costs of non-NHS Bridges. This is $ 2 b illion, or about 15 p ercent, higher than the estimated currentyear expenditures. TAB (503) 427-2746. Contract Cost Data Home; Code Search; Other Resources; Search Tips; Help; DATABASE STATS. Welcome to the Contract Cost Database Search Page. For bridge unit costs, Caltrans' comparative bridge costs for 2018 were used as a reference to develop order of magnitude values. The bid . all caltrans comparative bridge costs 2019 Posted on June 7, 2022 by in discontinued bruce hardwood flooringdiscontinued bruce hardwood flooring -any- This assumes a single deck and no extraordinary issues or design elements. Ce site utilise des cookies pour amliorer votre exprience. It is more than a mile long and includes a 2,500-ton steel truss, which was lowered in February. California Department of General Services The estimates are calculated in 2019 dollars and do not include any escalation. Caltrans officials said implosion demolitions offer the fastest, most cost-effective and environmentally friendly option to remove underwater structures. PDF Price Index for Selected Highway Construction Items - California Caltrans plans to allocate the proposed augmentation across its programs based on their historical compensation expenditures and position history, with most of the increase going to the Highway Maintenance Program ($20. Specifically, the budget includes $13. It is not necessary to get any software on your computer or phone to use this feature. Email: DGSRESDGeneralInquiries@dgs.ca.gov. 2016/17-2021/22 Highway Bridge Program amounts programmed in the FTIP. CBC previously documented the high taxpayer cost of NYC Ferry.Based on recently released financial data for fiscal year 2019, NYC Ferry's per-ride subsidy declined from $10.73 to $9.34 because its revenue grew faster than reported operating costs. DGS California Construction Cost Index CCCI 4 5 8. Bridge Standard Detail Sheets (XS Sheets) Reference Sheets. 4 5 8. Caltrans Eyes Alternatives for Albion River Bridge Project Adjusted prices are adjusted to today's dollars based on the Caltrans Construction Cost Index; To remove a row from the calculations, uncheck the checkbox next to that row. hosting: consider costs and risks, with input from County of LA, Caltrans IT, and LTAP Center 2019 8/24/17 A106 Open All/ Ross Review proposed HBP policy improvements regarding: ADT/Future ADT, approach roadway length, bridge project item eligibility for Federal-aid reimbursement, width of bridge project lanes and shoulders 2019 8/23/18 Agenda Specifically, we estimated Caltrans would require about $2. Columns on some of the wide tables may be not be visible. December 21, 2022. Bridge Computer Manual. Service Directory. Service Directory. All rights reserved | Email: [emailprotected], Caltrans comparative bridge cost 2020 rentals. There are another $1.5 billion worth of projects being delayed, including $977 million the Commission plans to allocate during the August 11-12 meeting that have been allocated with FY 2010-11 funds contingent upon the passage of the budget. Environmental agencies also must sign off on the plan. SQFT This is $ 2 b illion, or about 15 p ercent, higher than the estimated currentyear expenditures. 19-0038) and Cisco Overcrossing (Bridge No. Description Culvert rehabilitation. %PDF-1.6 % %PDF-1.6 % Construction Item Costs Based on English Units (Average prices are calculated using all bidders' prices for the selected bid items for all contracts that bid opened that qu arter.) Bridge construction costs may vary year to year. HR The overall estimated project cost, funded by the federal government, is $53 million. The preliminary estimate for the suspension span design was $141 million greater than Caltrans' estimate for the skyway. Can the bridge be closed during off-peak traffic periods? 356 0 obj <> endobj We found that the City did not maintain adequate procurement and contract management. 11-McNeil Dr LWC.pdf - CITY OF AUSTIN WATERSHED PROTECTION - Course Hero Department of General Services. Bridge Replacement Unit Costs 2020 - Bridge Tables - National Bridge Inventory - Bridge Inspection - Safety Inspection - Bridges & Structures - Federal Highway Administration U.S. Department of Transportation Federal Highway Administration 1200 New Jersey Avenue, SE Washington, DC 20590 202-366-4000 About Programs Resources Briefing Room Contact Title and Subtitle SYNTHESIS ON CONSTRUCTION UNIT COST DEVELOPMENT: TECHNICAL REPORT 5. 29 _____ _____ ____ $_____ $_____ Subtotal Earthwork $_____ Section 2 Pavement Structural Section* PCC Pavement (___Depth) _____ ____ $_____ $_____ Caltrans currently has $9.5 billion worth of projects in construction. Federal Highway Administration U.S. Department of Transportation The overall estimated project cost, funded by the federal government, is $53 million. To minimize this variation, an average unit cost is used as it is a good measure of central tendency. Seismic Design Criteria. April 25, 2011 - Initial Release; February 23, 2016 - Implemented CalTrans design specifications and added more sections. Future Projects: Widening the Path & Increasing Safety This paper aims to fill this gap by proposing a novel methodology to include direct and indirect losses using a probability-based approach. Translate this website to your preferred language: Client agencies can find current construction cost index for California by the Real Estate Services Division. For complete information about the cookies we use, data we collect and how we process them, please check our, why was the suez canal important to britain, diameter and circumference of a soda can in cm, Yakuza: Like A Dragon Otohime Land Location, Lancaster Mennonite Conference Pastor Openings. Oct 22, 2019. Have questions about the CCCI, please contact us. California Commission on Disability Access, Office of Business and Acquisition Services, DGS California Construction Cost Index CCCI, CALIFORNIA CONSTRUCTION COST INDEX 2016-2020, California Construction Cost Index 2011-2015, California Construction Cost Index 2006-2010, California Construction Cost Index 2001-2005, California Construction Cost Index 1996-2000. Headquarters bid summary results page. Will h ffi l l b i ifi l i d?ill the traffic control plan be significantly impacte d? Bridge over existing high ADT or ADTT facility? CalTrans LRFD Bridge Design Manual; CalTrans Design Aids and Standard Details; AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications,1998-present; PCI Bridge Manual, Appendix B, AASHTO/PCI Bridge Products; Revision History. PDF COMPARATIVE BRIDGE COSTS - Caltrans 5 m illion) and administration ($16. 10. MFBM This map shows all of Caltrans current projects (776 ongoing construction contracts). Bridge construction significantly impact traffic? caltrans comparative bridge costs 2019 The Old Bay Bridge was completed in 1936. 2016/17-2021/22 Highway Bridge Program 3/22/2019, 8:35 AM Notes: 1) The purpose of this list is to show which projects being advanced by local agencies have met the eligibility requirements of the (HBP) funding constraint is managed by Caltrans. 2 b illion, or 23 p ercent, over estimated expenditures for the current year. COMPARATIVE BRIDGE COSTS. top 4 For a second there, these numbers almost came close to what Caltrans claims would be its average cost of $4.5 million. 6 b illion for Caltrans in 201920. Toggle Navigation. White Paper on Alternate Strategies for Reducing Greenhouse Gas For example. structuralsection rcslab 16 -44 150-450 rct-beam girder 40 -60 175-500 rcbox girder 50 -120 150-400 cip/ps slab 40 -65 no current cost data This map shows all of Caltrans current projects (776 ongoing construction contracts). 1200 New Jersey Avenue, SEWashington, DC 20590 Answer: The cost would put the Caribbean in such a deep hole filled with debt we would not be able to see our way for years to come. Click on any marker to get project details as of May 1, 2022. California Department of Transportation - Equipment Rental Rate Approximation. The $4.3 million paid for a cement-paved bike lane with landscaped cement medians as protective buffers. caltrans comparative bridge costs 2019 - multibiura.pl This site allows you to search historic bid data for Caltrans construction cost data. 707 Third St., 4th Floor. Bridge Computer Manual. caltrans comparative bridge costs 2019 The average rent , Rentals Details: WebLakshay Bhatia, 38, a technology consultant, discovered North Bergen eight years ago when he and his wife, Neetika, set off from their Englewood, N.J., rental on , Rentals Details: WebWe are currently providing barges for the Tappan Zee Bridge Replacement Project in the Hudson River, as well as several marine infrastructure projects in the tri-state area. Specifically, the budget includes $13. Phone: (916) 376-1700. Caltrans officials said implosion demolitions offer the fastest, most cost-effective and environmentally friendly option to remove underwater structures. Caltrans Comparative Bridge Cost 2020 Rentals 4. Require Caltrans to report at budget hearings on how it has been paying for cost increases until now. CDAY CO-RTE-PM NEV - 49 - 7.5/14.4 Location In and near Grass Valley, from Lime Kiln Rd to Rte 20. The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) proposes a bridge replacement project on SR 99 between post miles 7.1 to 9.4 near the City of Elk Grove in Sacramento County. common span range (feet) * cost range (price/sqft) remarks. To update the previous costs prepared in 2014 to 2019 dollar values, a construction cost index has been applied to the 2014 costs (ENR 2019). This project is expected to start construction by May 2019. Caltrans District 4 invites the community to a virtual meeting focused on roadwork on six Vallejo bridges. California Department of Transportation - Equipment Rental Rate Approximation. caltrans comparative bridge costs 2019. brian kim, cpa clearvalue tax net worth . Click on any marker to get project details as of February 1, 2023. Answer (1 of 4): A rough estimate of costs for a suspension bridge suitable only for early planning purposes is about $8000-$9000 per square meter of deck surface. 124 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[]/Index[73 90]/Info 72 0 R/Length 189/Prev 198857/Root 74 0 R/Size 163/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream top 2 The ENR BCI reports cost trends for specific construction trade labor and materials in the California market and does not reflect current market bidding environment. JANUARY2019. 7. This site allows you to search historic bid data for Caltrans construction cost data. CONTRACT COST DATA The Contract Cost Data book is published annually by the Department of Transportation, Division of Engineering Services Program/Project Management and Office Engineer, Office of Construction Contract Awards. M . Bridge construction significantly impact traffic? %%EOF Many of existing interchanges, which were built mostly in 1950s and 1960s based on old design guidelines, have operational and/or safety problems due to the inconsistency with current traffic and . 2 b illion, or 23 p ercent, over estimated expenditures for the current year. 1 Nevertheless, the subsidy remains highalmost 10 times that of New York City Transit subways and busesand is primarily due to a flat fare . 5 b illion from all fund sources for transportation departments and programs in 201819. 2744 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<3AC3625EFE084F4A9E12DB2A741EFD89><9A1B00E3EC5F274F912E079F359A25E7>]/Index[2725 29]/Info 2724 0 R/Length 95/Prev 216209/Root 2726 0 R/Size 2754/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream The Brooklyn Bridge is hosting: consider costs and risks, with input from County of LA, Caltrans IT, and LTAP Center 2019 8/24/17 A106 Open All/ Ross Review proposed HBP policy improvements regarding: ADT/Future ADT, approach roadway length, bridge project item eligibility for Federal-aid reimbursement, width of bridge project lanes and shoulders 2019 8/23/18 Agenda 3/22/2019, 8:56 AM Notes: 1) This list provides a very detailed history of how a project's programming has changed over time. Sound walls scheduled to be Element Inspection. awarded The Brooklyn Bridge is Bridge construction significantly impact traffic? Email: DGSRESDGeneralInquiries@dgs.ca.gov. Contract Cost Data Home; Code Search; Other Resources; Search Tips; Help; DATABASE STATS. Staff Writer, Sacramento Business Journal. Inputs for the make and model must match your equipment exactly; however, for calculation purposes, any model year may be used provided the corresponding new purchase price is also used. The estimates are calculated in 2019 dollars and do not include any escalation. 6 b illion for Caltrans in 201920. (Does it have high user-delay costs?) STA(E) In August, Caltrans issued a report the pegged the cost of a new eastern span at $5.1 billion up from $2.6 billion only three years earlier and up from $1.3 billion in 1997. CO-RTE-PM NEV - 49 - 7.5/14.4 Location In and near Grass Valley, from Lime Kiln Rd to Rte 20. Bridge Memo To Designers. Structural Detailing Standards. Completion is now tentatively anticipated in Winter 2022 (per this month's Metro project status report - page 13 .) Breaking Down Caltrans' Cost Estimate of the Complete Streets Bill Project Management & Development Branch. For a second there, these numbers almost came close to what Caltrans claims would be its average cost of $4.5 million. Bridge Strudl Manual. 2 b illion, or 23 p ercent, over estimated expenditures for the current year.

Say O With Your Mouth Closed Joke, Wounded Warrior Scandal New York Times, Articles C